Among the newly banned cards is Mana Crypt, a staple in both casual and competitive decks. Known for its ability to generate explosive mana early in the game, its ban was anticipated by some who viewed it as overly dominant. However, for those who invested heavily in this iconic artifact, the decision feels like a significant blow.
Another notable casualty is Dockside Extortionist, a goblin that has long been a mainstay in red decks. While many agree it was a powerful enabler for high-cost strategies, its banning is seen by some as unjust, given its role in forcing interactions and adding excitement to the game. The collective sighs from red deck enthusiasts can almost be heard nationwide.
The banning of Nadu was perhaps less surprising, as many players felt his presence created unfun game states with lengthy, convoluted combos. However, some argue that it’s peculiar to see him banned before other high-impact cards, like Thassa’s Oracle, raising questions about the committee’s priorities.
One of the most bewildering decisions is the ban of a card that can only be played in Commander. Players are scratching their heads over the decision, especially since this card recently received a full art reprint. Its unique ability to produce mana for commanders might not seem oppressive, leading many to question the rationale behind its removal from the format.
The divisiveness of these bans has sparked discussions about the need for separate ban lists for cEDH and casual play. Many believe that high-powered players should be able to enjoy their favorite cards without restrictions while still maintaining a balanced environment for casual gamers.
As the community grapples with these changes, one thing remains clear: the spirit of Commander is still alive and well, as players find ways to adapt and enjoy the game they love. For those feeling disheartened, the idea of Rule Zero—the informal agreement among players to establish house rules—still offers a glimmer of hope.
For more details, check out the full RC article. Whether you agree with the bans or not, the conversation around Commander is far from over, and it’s clear that players will continue to voice their opinions as the format evolves.
